Online Colleges Are Quietly Failing Thousands of Students Right Now — Here Is What Forbes Just Exposed

📖 7 min read📊 Difficulty: Easy⭐ Practical value: Very High

Key Takeaways

  • A major Forbes investigation published this month revealed universities are struggling to keep up with surging online enrollment — and students are paying the price in quality.
  • A 2022 Statista survey found 73% of online college students in the US expressed concerns about the quality of instruction — and global trends mirror this closely.
  • The online college demand crisis affects students worldwide, not just in one country.
  • There are specific red flags you can check before enrolling that most people skip entirely.
  • Cohort-based programs have completion rates up to 3 times higher than self-paced courses — this one fact should change how you shop for programs.

The Forbes Story That Stopped Me Cold This Week

I came across a Forbes piece published just days ago with a headline that genuinely made me pause: Online Learning’s Moment: How Colleges Struggle To Meet Rising Demand. I assumed it would be a cheerleading piece about how online education is booming. It was not. It was a pretty uncomfortable look at how the online college demand crisis is leaving real students — people who paid real money — getting a lot less than they bargained for.

The core problem? Demand for online programs exploded after 2020, grew even faster through 2024, and now in 2026 universities are still scrambling to catch up. Hiring qualified online instructors is hard. Building proper digital infrastructure costs money. And scaling a program fast often means cutting corners on the thing that actually matters — the learning experience.

Why the Online College Demand Crisis Is a Global Problem

Here’s what surprised me most: this is not an American story. The World Bank estimated in a 2024 report that over 220 million students globally are currently enrolled in some form of distance or online education. That number has nearly doubled since 2019. Europe, Southeast Asia, Latin America — every region is seeing this same surge.

And yet a Statista survey found that 73% of online college students expressed concerns about instruction quality. A separate study from the Open University in the UK found that nearly 60% of online learners felt they lacked adequate tutor feedback. These are not niche problems. This is the majority of online students feeling underserved.

The uncomfortable truth is that a lot of universities launched online programs not because they were ready — but because they saw enrolment revenue walking out the door if they didn’t. Speed over substance.

“Colleges are essentially building the plane while flying it — enrolling thousands of students into programs that were designed in under six months.” — Forbes, May 2026

What ‘Struggling to Meet Demand’ Actually Looks Like for Students

Let me translate that Forbes headline into real student experiences, because the abstract phrase ‘struggling to meet demand’ hides a lot of specific failures.

It looks like this: you pay €8,000 for a one-year online business diploma. Your ‘instructor’ is a part-time adjunct hired three weeks before the course started. The video lectures are clearly recycled from a 2021 in-person course — zero redesign for online format. You post a question in the course forum on a Tuesday. You get a reply eleven days later. That is not education. That is a PDF subscription service with a diploma at the end.

Online College Demand Crisis: What Students Lose | PickSurely

It also looks like enrolment caps being silently removed. Forbes specifically noted that several major institutions were accepting far more students per course than any single instructor could meaningfully support. One example cited: a single online discussion thread monitored by one teaching assistant for 340 students. Think about that for a second.

The online college demand crisis is basically a supply-demand mismatch — demand sprinted ahead, supply quality never caught up, and students are left holding an expensive, undercooked experience.

The Red Flags Most Students Completely Miss Before Enrolling

I spent a couple of hours after reading the Forbes piece pulling together the signals that separate properly resourced online programs from the ones that are just chasing enrolment numbers. Most people skip all of these.

Question to AskRed Flag AnswerGood Answer
What is the student-to-instructor ratio?Over 80:1Under 30:1
Is the program accredited?Vague or evasive answerNamed accrediting body, verifiable online
What is the average response time for instructor feedback?“Within a few weeks”48–72 hours guaranteed
What is the completion rate?Refuses to share data60%+ with evidence
Is there a live/synchronous component?Fully pre-recorded onlyAt least bi-weekly live sessions

That last one about completion rates is worth sitting with. The average completion rate for fully self-paced MOOCs — those are the massive open online courses from platforms like Coursera or edX — hovers around 5 to 15 percent according to MIT research. Cohort-based programs, where you move through material with a fixed group, perform dramatically better. This might be wrong but I genuinely think cohort structure is the single biggest quality signal you can look for.

What the Online College Demand Crisis Means for Your Next Decision

Look, I’m not saying online education is bad. Some of the best learning I’ve ever done has been online. But the Forbes investigation is a useful reminder that ‘online’ is not automatically equal to ‘flexible and affordable quality learning.’ Right now, in 2026, there is a real gap between the best and worst online programs — and that gap is wider than most people realise.

The students getting burned are mostly the ones who enrolled based on a slick website and a low price. The ones coming out satisfied? They asked hard questions upfront, chose accredited programs with reasonable class sizes, and specifically looked for live instructor access.

Honestly, the online college demand crisis is fixable — but it’s going to take universities investing properly in instructional design, hiring qualified online educators, and being honest about their capacity. Until that happens, the burden of quality-checking is on you as the student.

Use the planner below to figure out exactly what to look for based on your situation. It’ll take you two minutes and might save you thousands.

🎓 Online Learning Readiness Planner

Answer 4 quick questions and get a personalised action plan for picking the right online college program.

1 of 4 — What is your main reason for studying online?

Last updated: May 09, 2026

Disclaimer: The content on PickSurely is for informational purposes only and should not be considered professional financial, legal, or medical advice. Always consult a qualified professional before making important decisions.

Leave a Comment